Excellent commentary, Joe. I hope my thoughts can do it justice.
First off, a re-iteration of the thanks to the Host Organism and the King of DrexelSpace for their efforts in organizing the event. As much as they always like to credit the audience, we're lazy ... we just buy the tickets. This stuff is hard work.
A few general thoughts before we begin ...
I too count this as probably one of the weaker lineups in the past few years. Still, I think the lineups' strengths (the premieres) went well and it's weaknesses (lack of classics, less-than-optimal film order) did not weigh it down to any serious extent.
Concerning DVD projection, I am with Joe in being a 35mm purist, though I can generally be somewhat forgiving in many cases. Still, I felt there was way too much DVD projection this time around. Though the projector is very good, midway through "Richard Garriott" I definitely hit my "Ok, I'm tired of scan-lines, this is way too much video" limit. It could be because it was mostly front-loaded, but I'd had enough. Still, in many cases it can't be helped.
I won't say much about projection problems because for the most part things went very smoothly. Frames were taken care of quickly, the focus was good and the projectionists were very responsive. There were a number of audio problems during Intermissions and with several films, but this seemed to stem mostly from switchovers between film and DVD. Methinks if DVD is going to be this much of the lineup that the Drexel may need to review its patchboard configuration. That, or reduce the amount of DVD next year.
As for the lineup itself, in general it was good but I do think it concentrated far too heavily on the "premieres" and recent films and needed at least one or two films from pre-1968 in the mix. (And that's AFTER considering the "Moon" swap-out.)
And again, let me point out that even being critical, I definitely consider this Marathon to be a Success.
Alright, on to the REALLY long, boring commentary.
MOON - This was a genuinely crushing disappointment to lose. It was a perfect film to show (most people never got to see it in the all-enveloping environs of a darkened theater) and a genuinely receptive crowd to show it to. Though I love its replacement (the "Thing From Another Reel") with all my heart and soul, losing this hurt bad.
Stingray Sam - Wow. Friggin' perfect. Shown in the perfect way in the perfect venue. (Admittedly, it might become a bit tedious in a single dose, but done serially it was fantastic.) Fun, irreverent, enjoyable ... and a musical, no less! This is the sort of thing we come to Marathons for, the "surprise hits" that most of us know nothing about. Plus, David Hyde Pierce's best vocal work since
The Amazing Screw-On Head <-(Look this up and WATCH IT, by the way. I don't think you'll be disappointed.)
Ink - Joe and I diverge here, though I think his points are very valid. Still, after watching it I felt like overall it worked, and worked pretty well. It pulls cliches from a LOT of sources (more which a Recognized Horror Expert like Mr. Neff would readily recognize), and its hook was pretty obvious about 1/2-way in, but I found myself enjoying it despite all this. Not the greatest premiere the Marathon has run, but worth seeing. I'd even forgive it on DVD if the lineup weren't already so DVD-heavy.
Spaceboy - Admittedly, the audience was a bit harsh/dismissive of Mike Olenick, which is a shame - but in their defense,
Spaceboy is a hard sell, even amongst those whose tastes cross a broad spectrum. Not everyone, for example, holds your love of
Suspiria, Joe.
Richard Garriott: Man On a Mission - Excellent documentary, and a glimpse into the inner workings of the Soviet Space Agency and the ISS is always welcome. That said, my neo-Marxist side kept thinking, "Geez, THIS is what this guy did with all that Ultima cash I gave him?" Still, ultimately I was glad to see it and I think it's extremely well done. I admit, I want to like the guy even if he does have more money than he knows what to do with.
Costume Contest - Please, people, let's see some more/better entrants in the future. Ro-Man has jumped the shark, his seat of power CAN be usurped. Costume and presentation, it can be done. No, really, some of us WILL vote for you.
Geharha - Missed bits of this ordering a pizza, but didn't miss much. An amusing enough lark, with genuinely funny moments, though not the screaming riot I had hoped for. Still, by the end I was genuinely chuckling and managed the occasional guffaw.
Sleep Dealer - An excellent gem, and the title that I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY WISH they had gotten on film (I had thought there were prints available, though maybe I'm wrong there.) I echo Joe's comments exactly. Definitely resonated well with me and I think it's an excellent entrant in the catalog for Mexico.
Godzilla vs King Ghidorah - Oh, yeah, this is Godzilla-kitsch at its best (and worst.) Ridiculous plotlines and rubber suits, everything I've come to love about Gojira. I truly enjoyed it, though for my money I'd rather see a pristine 1960s kaiju (i.e. "Mothra") than the modern reboots.
The Lost Skeleton Returns Again - Again, I'm with Joe here. Blamire can call me when he learns how to be funny. He's the king of Beating a Dead Joke and neither he, nor his editors (nor indeed most of his actors) have any sense of comedic timing. They also lack an understanding of the idea of "funny once." I would have probably dropped it entirely in favor of any number of other titles.
Battle In Outer Space - This was where the sleep deprivation started to catch up with me. I know I nodded off for about 45 minutes, maybe an hour, right in the middle. Kinda disappointing, since I did want to see it, but it's a rough time slot for a classic.
Star Trek - This is now the 5th time I've sat through this, and though I'm not quite as critical as Joe on the film, it consistently can't peek its head above 3.5/5 stars in my book. I will say this, what it does well, I think it does VERY well and quite enjoyably. Its flaws, however, are FUNDAMENTAL flaws, and they're big, and I just can't get past them. It's a pity, too, because this much effort and money could have made a reboot of genuine quality, rather than just another re-hacked franchise cash-cow. It's too recent, too, given its popularity ... I would have let this vintage sit for at least a year or two before bringing it up to Marathon status.
Galaxina - Yeah, this is really a bad film. But then, it's SUPPOSED to be a bad film. 70's/80's schlock at its glorious worst. At least it doesn't take itself too seriously. Sadly, there's another 30-minute gap in there which I just don't remember (though I suspect I didn't miss much) so I'm sure I nodded off once more. I enjoy this sort of thing, (I actually laughed more at this than at
Cadavra if you can believe it), but it needed a better time slot. Hey,
Cadavra looks like a good place.
2010 - I almost skipped out early on this one, but the print was in pretty good shape and I hadn't seen it for a very long time (in spite of having the BluRay sitting on top of the pile right now.) Other than the political atmosphere, which overwhelms the film and is difficult taken in modern context, I think it holds up extremely well. It's certainly a worthy successor to the Masterpiece (which I think holds up better at 42 than I do at 40 :/), and it was good enough to keep me awake after a very long, very heavy Marathon. Again, though, there could have been a better spot for it. I probably would have made it the opener.
Premieres I would REALLY, REALLY, REALLY LIKE to have seen ...
Cargo,
The Adventures of Adele Blanc-Sec,
Splice (though it's out soon anyway, I believe),
Black Lightning,
Scott Pilgrim vs the World, heck even
Iron Man 2 would have been a fun surprise. Still, what they got was good and I have no complaints. Keep an eye out for all the above titles, as they'll be coming somewhere nearby reasonably soon.
One thing I wanted to add for anyone out there that lurks, or who has wandered here from Facebook or Twitter. Please, WE'D LOVE TO HEAR WHAT YOU THINK. The registration process might be a bit cumbersome, but the admins can help and we're always looking for feedback. We'll take it anywhere you want to put it (comments on Facebook are good as well.)
I'm sure there are people who would love to hear an opinion other than our Merry Band of Talking Heads.
And really, that's all I have to say about that. I'll start scanning the materials from the 'thon this week and get them into the Archives, and I should have the Hall of Marathonia updated tomorrow, if I can still remember anything by then.
Oh, and if people are interested in the list of songs from the Intermission music, I can post those here this week as well.