Well, the reason I love the inclusion of Irreversible is the EXACT reason that LA doesn't - because it IS BORDERLINE horror. You have to admit that having Stuart there to introduce and talk about the film will make it all the more interesting. I am sure he will talk about many of the same things we are discussing on this board. If he doesn't, I hope someone asks him the question - "Why he thinks it is a horror film." Joe, it is your duty to do this!
Funny, I had this discussion over lunch...well...maybe over several lunches through the course of a weekend with another group of my friends. Nobody could agree on exactly what a horror film was, but it was an interesting discussion nonetheless. One person thought that Taxi Driver was a horror film. I didn't, necessarily. It is discussions like these that provoke thought and help forward genre and allow us to study and learn.
REGARDING HENRY
Now - I think Henry is a horror film....it's hard for me to defend though because I have not seen it in 15 years or more! If the film were told from the perspectives of the victims, I think nobody would question that it wasn't a horror film. This is why nobody says Halloween isn't a horror film - it's told form the perspective of the victims. OK - there are a few POV camera scenes, but those are for effect. In general the story is about Laurie Strode and her friends. THIS is what make Henry interesting. It's a genre film FLIPPED inside out and told from the perspective of the killer. By the way, I realize this is not the first film to do this, afterall Maniac far preceded Henry. I wonder if any of you would consider Devil's Rejects a horror film. It pretty much does the same thing as Henry, however, I admit that I did not care for the film, though I do think that it is a horror film.
So what is a horror film? Horror films are those films that deal with and evoke horror. OK, so that sounds lame....BUT let me go on... The dictionary definition of horror is:
HORROR - Noun- An overwhelming and painful feeling caused by something frightfully shocking, terrifying, or revolting; a shuddering fear: to shrink back from a mutilated corpse in horror.
So is a something like Taxi Driver a horror film....well it could be. What about Flight 93. Is that a horror film? Well, with flight 93, it certainly deals with horrifying material and so does Taxi Driver. Flight 93 is about terrorist who hijack a plane and attempt to kill all 50 passengers by crashing the plane.
SPOILER ALERT (Taxi Driver)
Taxi Driver ends in a bloodbath. With Travis Bickle killing the Pimp and his posse.
SPOIL OVER
It is violent and difficult to watch. However, with those films, I contend that the principle focus is not on the horror. With Taxi Driver it is an examination of of society and a member of society, Travis Bickle, who does not fit in. Some may say that Travis Bickle is like an avenging Angel cleansing society and "washing away all the filth" from the streets. Bickel doesn't quite fit in, so in some ways he is his own entity separate from society and all it's norms, thus he is like an avenging angel from above. Flight 93 focuses on Heroism. Sure it is about horrible deeds, but the focus is on heroism and the act of saving. So personally I don't think either are horror films. NOW, definitely Flight 93 is not a horror film, but I CAN see the arguments for Taxi Driver and who knows....with more thought on the matter I may come around to TD as a horror film. In fact, I may have to revisit the film, as I have not seen it in about 15 years. This time watching it, I will try and see it as a horror film.
Back to the definition. Even though the word Horror, is easily defined by Webster dictionary, it is still hard to define and pinpoint what a horror film is. This is because horror changes and WHAT a horror film is changes as time goes by because what horrifies us and shocks us changes. It wasn't until after the industrial age that "serial" killers became more prevalant. The fear of nuclear creatures from the bottom of the sea could not have existed before the invention of the nuclear bomb. When Frankenstein was written, the fear of serial killers was not as much in the conscious mind as the fear of Ghouls, Vampires, Werewolves, and animated corpses. Let's face it...seems that those "supernatural" fears will always be with us. It's burned into our subconcious. The fear and horror of serial killers is something that is relatively new. Thus we have the slasher genre and the serial killer genre. I think that Henry is a continuation of the slasher genre....it's a horror film told from the point of view of the killer. It is a genre beding film.
WHAT ABOUT IRREVERSIBLE
Well....too hard for me to argue this one too...as I have not seen it since it came out. I was certainly freaked out by it. I am not even sure I think that it is a horror film myself. I would have to see it again. Sooooo, I will be lame and not discuss it.
Wow....my thoughts are really scattered and I am just droning on.... Basically, I love that the Marathon includes these type of films. The marathon should not be all ghost films, or slasher films, or even all supernatural films. This is the chance to actually have an academic discussion with a group of horror fans and a famous director on a subject matter that is challenging and thought provoking. A very unique oppurtunity for all those in attendence. This is what makes the screening of this film special. I don't think Joe would have booked it had Stuart not suggested showing the title. Henry - Yes. I think Henry is more obviously horror than Irreversible, though even that is debatable. I mean, you could argue that Dead Alive is not a horror film, or DEFINITELY argue that Army of Darkness is not horror. Would anyone have trouble with those films showing....I doubt it. Hell, Army is a fantasy comedy with hardly any horror in it at all.
Horror should not always be safe! Horror has always pushed the envelope. To me the Horror Marathons are about the entire genre, border-line horror, classic horror, supernatural, etc etc. I gurantee people will be talking about this in the lobby. Yes, some people may be furious for such material screening. Some may be freaked out....but you know what, that is what horror does and that is why I am a genre fan.
PS - LA, the Columbus crowds are much more accepting of material such as this than the Boston crowds.
PSS - I didn't want to go too far into the discussion of what a horror film is....I could write a thesis on the subject! I could have went into and talked about iconography of horror, subgenre, etc....but I sort of ended my discussion a little early as I didn't want to REALLY start boring people.